Sherlock Holmes and the Happy Home
By Jeff McNair
By Jeff McNair
A family member had asked
Holmes to visit a local group home in order to determine whether there was any
likelihood of foul play in the choking death of a man at the group home. He and
Watson arrived and walked through the residence, Watson chatting with the man
who ran the home, while Holmes in his typical, keenly focused fashion, followed behind.
After the visit, they moved toward the door to leave,
Holmes appearing irritated and disinterested in any conversation with the man who
was the group home “parent”. Watson shook his hand cordially. But Holmes would
not make eye contact staring at the door indicating his interest in leaving. As
the door was opened, Holmes bumped it open further such that it pushed the man
back and he quickly walked out without a word. Embarrassed, Watson turned
to the man.
“Please forgive my friend he must have
something on his mind. Thank you for the opportunity to tour your home.”
“It was my pleasure” said the man with a
quizzical look on his face as his eyes followed and stayed on Holmes who waited
at the end of the driveway by a van too large for the typical family,
obviously disgruntled.
Watson nodded, half smiled and walked
toward Holmes slowly at first and then briskly as the door closed behind him.
“Why do you have to be like that?” he
asked. “That was a lovely home and the people living there were obviously satisfied
with their accommodations.”
“Was it? Were they?” Holmes responded
his voice rising in tone. “You really thought that was a lovely home and the
tenants satisfied?”
“Well, yes. Weren’t they?”
“Watson you once again see, but you do
not observe.” He responded. “We have had this discussion before.” His eyes
riveted on Watson’s. “Have you learned nothing?”
“It is a government funded home, you
cannot expect perfection. But the people there are happy, they have friends,
you saw the Christmas cards, they experience community integration as evidenced
by the award your friend received, and they seem to have the rights that would
go along with living as an adult with an intellectual disability in the
community.”
The look of disgust in Holmes’ eyes told
Watson that apparently they had visited very different places.
“’Rights without opportunities are
meaningless’ is how the reformer Irving Zola stated it. Must I describe to you
every flaw of that place which anyone with minimal powers of observation would
have clearly seen? Maybe you aren’t paying attention. Maybe you are satisfied
because of your low expectations. Maybe you need to know some people like those
incarcerated there. Maybe...” He paused and stared at Watson for a moment, then nodded
as if reaching a decision. “No, in your case it is probably all of the above.
But that is not a ‘home’ as you described it. Well it is a home, but I would
propose not a home that you or I would choose to live in if we had the ability
to make a choice which clearly those in the home do not.”
“I don’t understand why you are so
upset.”
“That is obvious.”
“Well, are you not going to tell me what
I overlooked. I believe you delight in that.”
“It is not that I delight in pointing
out your inadequacies though myriad. It is that in doing so I might jar your
slumbering mind into paying attention to the world around you, to which you are
apparently oblivious.”
Watson stared back, ready for the
onslaught which was typical of their interactions. With hands on hips he
prepared.
“What time was it when we rang the
bell?” asked Holmes.
“It was precisely 5:30.”
“Correct! How many adults do you know
who are in the practice of wearing their pajamas at 5:30, ready to go to bed at
6. Why would adults go to bed at 6 when they are not ill? Likely for the convenience of those who care for them. Additionally, they
all appeared to frequent the same barber who must have quite limited abilities
as they all had the exact same haircut. It would be difficult to go into a
public setting and gather 5 men who looked so identical.
“Then as we entered we were taken past
the kitchen. There we observed the largest poster illustrating the Heimlich
maneuver that perhaps I have ever seen. A bit late for the man who choked to
death. A menu was prominently placed on the refrigerator indicating the fare
for that evening was chicken breast with rice and vegetables. However, the
dishes in the sink were soiled by what appeared to be peanut butter and jelly
and at least one resident does not like bread crust.
“It was at that point that I recognized
my friend from Ethiopia, I noted that his right ear was reddened as if it had
been rubbed raw or perhaps struck. As the staff member/tour guide would approach Joe,
another resident, clearly he did so with great care, particularly if
approaching from his left side. It was as if he feared him. As I reached to greet
my friend with a pat on the right shoulder with my left hand I noted the slightest flinch on his
part. It was then I realized that Joe was my friend’s roommate, and concluded
that he is physically aggressive and had been hitting him. The aggressive man
was also left handed. Perhaps that is why there is a business card by the phone
for a behavior specialist who refers to herself as, “an expert in aggressive
behavior.”
“Through his family, I knew that my
friend grew up in Addis attending the Ethiopian Orthodox church there and as I
know there are no such congregations in this area I wondered whether he had
found another faith group. In his room there was a stack of bulletins from St.
John’s Catholic church, just down the street. The most recent bulletin was from
2012, two years ago. The oldest was from 1998 when my friend came to America
and likely was placed in the home. So as recently as two years ago, he was a
regular attendee at St. John’s. In preparation to come to this home, my
research revealed that the company which runs the home had changed hands two
years ago. If you recall, when I asked him if he was enjoying church, although from
the bulletins I knew he hadn’t attended in two years, he responded, “We are
taking a break from church.” This is not
the type of thinking that would be generated from someone who first, had a faith
background going back to his time in Ethiopia and who would enjoy church to the
point of collecting bulletins regularly for 14 years and second who had an intellectual disability. Obviously, those who now
run the home do not permit residents to express their religious preference.
“However, as you know from your time in
Africa, Watson, priests in the Ethiopian Orthodox church will carry a six inch
cross in their pocket which they use to bless people who would come to them for
assistance. Although my friend is not a priest, I noted that he carries such a
cross. It is apparently always in his pocked as evidenced by the faded pattern
on his jeans pocket in the shape of a cross. So, obviously these people are not
being given the opportunity to worship as they would like.”
“As you quoted Dr. Zola, Holmes,” Watson
responded, “ ‘Rights without opportunities are meaningless.’”
“Precisely.”
“But what of the Christmas cards and the
community integration award?” Watson responded.
“Upon entering, I also observed the
bulletin board where staff members would pick up their name badges when working
at the home. The names of two women were among the 5 badges. Those same two
names were on the Christmas cards that stood on the dresser of my friend’s room.
He has no community friends. He has no one outside of those people who are
paid to be with him.”
“...and the community integration
award?” asked Watson.
“Yes, I wondered at that myself.” Holmes
responded. “But like many of these places, they do not distinguish between
community integration and community presence which are very different things.
If you were to look closely at the award, the groups present at the gathering
were homes or workshops for adults with disabilities facilitated by state disability
agencies. Doubtless there was no one there with the adults, who was not paid to
be with them. Would you call that community integration?”
“Clearly not!” replied Watson.
“So those who purport to facilitate
community integration don’t know what it is.” Holmes paused, thinking. “But there were other disturbing things as
well. The actual house is nice, typical of this neighborhood. These places
generally have spacious backyards, fenced in, where someone might get away for a moment to clear their mind or
just enjoy being outside. As I looked, the grass in the yard had not been
watered for some time such that it was dry and the ground quite dusty. Now I do
not care about their garden, but there were no pathways through the dry grass,
no places where it had been pressed down by people walking on it. I also investigated
the shoes and pants of the residents and noted no dust or dirt like that in the
backyard. So the residents, once they are home, never go outside. They are kept
as prisoners inside the house. This might not be that sad if there were
activities which might provide diversions of sorts for them.”
“There was a television.” Watson
countered.
“Yes there was, but did you note a
remote?”
“Come to think of it I didn’t see one.”
“It was there, however, it was out of
reach of the residents on top of one of the book cases. There were several
table games on the shelves but they don’t look as if they had been taken down
for quite some time. So the residents don’t go outside, do not have control of
the television and as I am sure even you observed.” Watson bristled but kept
his attention on Holmes, “Their opportunities for amusement were Spartan at
best with very little to divert them other than Joe beating on my friend.”
Watson shook his head sadly.
“As I walked to my friend’s room, I
could just make out a name printed with a black marker that bled through his
collar. At first it didn’t make sense as it was not his name till I realized
that he doesn’t even own his own clothing but shares clothing communally with
the others. I wondered how far that went, till he leaned over to pick up
something off of the floor behind the headboard of his bed and a different name
appeared on his underwear.
“The object that my friend picked up was
a theater ticket that had fallen behind his bed. The dried out tape could no longer hold it to the wall. It too was dated prior to
2012. It was a 1997 performance of Les Miserables. I was glad that he got to
see that because I know he has always loved music. But that brought no
satisfaction as I lamented that perhaps the last time he was with a friend was
that evening in 1997, with me Watson. I knew his family when they arrived here but lost track of
them over the years as our lives went in different directions. It was I who
took him to the play. But I wonder now if I would even be permitted to take him
somewhere with the current oversight of his home.
"But the thing that saddened
me the most was the half-moon shaped callous on his wrist. Did you notice that,
Watson?” There was no response. “People will sometimes bite themselves in
frustration, Watson. My friend’s callous, so distinct, so deep was
communicating to me that his life has been hard. My hasty departure was only
partly because of my disgust. I also feel as if I have failed him.”
Posts
